Re: which time scale of fate line fits in your practice?

**Upendrasingh Bhadoriya** Sat Nov 20, 2010 4:44 am

Martijn , Stalin and other participants
Namskaram,
There are many titles of palmistry which are not traceable in web world but I am not sure about this title. Hereby I am putting name of same title “Sachitra Samudrik Rahsyam” in Hindi “सचित्र-सामुद्रिकरहस्यम् ” if any one can spell well in English is free to do this. I have many books of palmistry which are not familiar to modern palmistry even in fast moving era. Some of these are very peculiar so it can be used in India or in Indian society only. Our sages told us to use Sastra (science or knowledge) according to ‘देश’ (region) and ‘क़ाल’ (era) otherwise you will not find them perfect. And this advise applicable to all.
I want to quote a paragraph from the book “Lovers guide to palmistry” of Mary E. Anderson chapter-1 The Man’s Viewpoint page 13 –
‘Never marry a woman with square hand or she’ll rule your life’ is a quotation from the great palmist, Comte de St. Germain, Who wrote his greatest work Palmistry For Professional Purpose in 1897.
If picking a partner by the hand shape was important then. It is still important now. As society becomes more complex, so do the people live in it. For instance, a girl with square palm today is far more of an asset from point of view of being practical, hard-working and able to manage, because women today will not stand for being just a decoration and most women work anyway. Therefore, unless you have pot of money, marry a girl with square hands.
But still in my country some orthodox people do not allow dominating or working or intelligent life partner. For them it useless to choose square hand girl likewise there are many things of palmistry, which are not working universally. Hence though we have enough knowledge of palmistry, without knowing the culture of people we fail to assess them or give the answer of their question and predict their forth coming events.

**Martijn (admin)** Sat Nov 20, 2010 11:38 am

Upendrasingh Bhadoriya wrote:Martijn , Stalin and other participants
Namskaram,
There are many titles of palmistry which are not traceable in web world but I am not sure about this title. Hereby I am putting name of same title “Sachitra Samudrik Rahsyam” in Hindi “सचित्र-सामुद्रिकरहस्यम् ” if any one can spell well in English is free to do this. ...

Dear Mister Upendrasingh Bhadoriya,

Thank you very much for specifying your answer!

Aha...!! The original title was written in Hindi language! Smile

That explains why I could not find your title.

By the way, you made quite a few other interesting comments in your statement!!

Very interesting to hear that some Indian sages say that not all 'theories' can be applied outside the states where these are part of the culture.

I hope that our forum-friends who feel a passion for 'ancient palmistry' (such as: Stalin.v) will read your words carefully... because your examples point out why not all ancient knowledge is still usefull today! (Though basically this is of course not surprizing at all... for I think that idea is basically shared by most philosophies & religions around the world - which relates to the 'evolution' or ideas)

And I love the example regarding women with a square hand - it is even quite funny!! applause

Thanks again for sharing your experience & ideas!

Thumbs up!

**GoodPalmist** Sun Nov 21, 2010 1:53 am

This is just my humble opinion:

The old combinations are frequently unworkable in modern times. I've spoken to several astrologers. If the old meanings are applied verbatim to planetary combinations (and by extension to palm lines), they will often make no sense in modern times.

The most misleading are those relating to women's character. Some of the most intelligent, productive, far-sighted women would have been discarded in ancient times as 'useless' wives. Many bold, confident female go-getters and leaders would have been branded as unchaste, unfaithful and aggressive.

Those of us who rely rigidly on ancient palmistry are doing ourselves a big disservice by not recognizing the obselete combinations.
That said, I, in my own limited way, do use some ancient combinations to arrive at my own conclusions. After substantial practical investigation I either discard it or apply it with some modifications appropriate to changing times. My personal opinion is that it would be equally foolish to totally disregard ancient knowledge, but that is just my opinion and have no desire to argue with anyone who thinks otherwise.
GP

sv-b Sun Nov 21, 2010 1:13 pm

Hello goodpalmist, Smile

I dont want to debate with you. I consider your views with open mind. but, fact is exactly the opposite. sun , planets and stars are ancient. Indeed, it has not been modified in this modern times. The rules of ancients are perfect all the time if they were perfected beings. We , indians have the shrines of Goddesses. That alone can illustrate you how importance we give for women. The creation , sustenence, and destruction is not only occuring to the universe. It happens even in the womb of women, which is been termed menstrual cycle by the moderns. This is the manifestation we see. The main and center shrine compartment of every hindu temple is termed garbaha mandala. Meaning is womb(productive) manifested system. We hindu, use to revolve around the main compartment of the temple thrice or once or 108 times depends on the deities which we revolve. Still, we hindu know that the basic principle gives ways for both monotheism and polytheism. It is not only idolatry. when we revolve those shrines, we have to undertand that it is equal to revolving the whole universe , being a manifestation. It is nearly initial devotion of hindus. The ideal devotion could be obtained by spritualist through penance. They dont need idols for their devotion.

Palm wont say lie. but, peoples can. This is where we miss our verifications. Smile

astroman123 Wed Feb 16, 2011 12:02 am

wow, hot discussion here
i don't have any feedback with regards to timing techniques in palmistry, but i would like to share with you my knowledge of timing techniques in face reading. Some of you may find it helpful.

There are different schools of timing in Chinese face reading. Some people believe we should read from the client's left if he's a guy and from the right if she's a woman. Others believe this isn't necessary.

The next question comes when it comes to age. In modern times we aren't considered 21 unless we have reached our 21st birthday, but in ancient times (and modern Korea) we are considered age 1 once we are born. Our age grows by 1 every February 4th (the first day of spring according to the Chinese calendar). In other words, a baby that was just born on February 3rd would be considered two years of age by the next day! Some believe we should use modern age, while others argue we should use the Chinese age.

Then there's a question with regards to body size and timing techniques. According to a Chinese classic events would happen one or two years earlier than what appears on the face if the person is slender, and one or two years later if the person is obese events would happen two or yeas later than expected.

So, in other words, accuracy is +3 or -3 years. But from my experience accuracy is about +1 or -1 year. The harder part is to be able to see the mark/scar/sign.

**nonas_insights** Sun Jun 05, 2011 12:57 am

Interesting to read different approaches.
I had never seen heart line timed starting form the percussion. In this respect I follow William Benham's timing and it seems to work well that way.

So far I have found that the junction of the fate line with the head line is about 30 years of age, and the junction of the fate line with the heart line is about 50 years of age. If the fate line runs into the base of the Saturn finger it generally has indicated that longevity runs in that family, ie many close relatives living to a minimum of 80 years of age.

I find the timing on Waxman's hand for the lifeline to fall in with what I have discovered too.
Nona sunny

**curiouswoman** Sun Jun 05, 2011 4:40 am

I agree with you Nonas. i feel the same way Thumb up

Lunes Mon Jun 06, 2011 10:14 am

Hello,
last year I got a handreading with numerological recommendations from J. Berus
(his website `JürgenBerusHandlesen`is one of the 58).
He asked me:What was with 40? I said to him:I married.
It was a cloudy day , but we were laughing after these words.
I`ve ten loops, long mirrors and moon in geminis. So I`ve no problems to accept
different systems. It`s more interesting to get the right points.
Lunes
P.S.: The system of G.S. Birla seems to be well balanced

**Hok** Wed Jul 27, 2011 2:16 am

Patti wrote:
Also, I have found that in reality, the fate line marks itself downwards in parallel to the lifeline from around early to mid 30's (age on life line). This method (not a system) would show the fate line marks itself in response to current events in one area, yet can still be read in the other area (crossing head line). I read the direction of the fate line as it crosses the headline as defining the directions in life a person is pulled toward whereas the markings that appear in parallel to the life line, are more related to current situations. I haven't thought to document this previously, but now that I have, I will watch for it and take some photos.

Patti

Hi Patti,
Can you please explain on this a little bit more with an example.

**pravin kumar** Wed Jul 27, 2011 12:51 pm

Dear Hok,

Benham has different chart, Cheiro has different chart and Narayan Dutt Shrimali has a different chart. Benham takes the maximum age a person lives to be 70. I am quoting from memory, Cheiro takes it as 91 or 98 (Systems of seven) and Narayan Dutt Shrimali takes it as 100 years. Now neither is right or all are right. Which method you want to follow and get results is the best method for you. If you have some other chart in your mind or way of calculation and it brings you success well and good. I am inspired by W.G. Benham but for age I follow Cheiro's method in which I get good success. In the case of Heart Line though I follow the starting point to be below the Jupitor Finger, centre of the mount and from there I calculate the age. I take that to be the starting point and the ending below the mercury finger.

Once I had a discussion with Ed Campbell and he said he follows it the other way round. Actually we were discussing about a palm print in that forum. It so happened that both ways the age was correct as the point was in the centre of the heart line. Still I told him that whatever method is followed should give us the correct result.

Secondly if you read palms regularly and your desire is to solve other persons problems genuinely you will find your intuition going stronger and you will be surprised at yourself when you start giving the age predictions.

Pravin Kumar

**Hok** Wed Jul 27, 2011 4:00 pm

pravin kumar wrote:Dear Hok,

Benham has different chart, Cheiro has different chart and Narayan Dutt Shrimali has a different chart. Benham takes the maximum age a person lives to be 70. I am quoting from memory, Cheiro takes it as 91 or 98 (Systems of seven) and Narayan Dutt Shrimali takes it as 100 years. Now neither is right or all are right. Which method you want to follow and get results is the best method for you. If you have some other chart in your mind or way of calculation and it brings you success well and good. I am inspired by W.G. Benham but for age I follow Cheiro's method in which I get good success. In the case of Heart Line though I follow the starting point to be below the Jupitor Finger, centre of the mount and from there I calculate the age. I take that to be the starting point and the ending below the mercury finger.

Once I had a discussion with Ed Campbell and he said he follows it the other way round. Actually we were discussing about a palm print in that forum. It so happened that both ways the age was correct as the point was in the centre of the heart line. Still I told him that whatever method is followed should give us the correct result.

Secondly if you read palms regularly and your desire is to solve other persons problems genuinely you will find your intuition going stronger and you will be surprised at yourself when you start giving the age predictions.

Pravin Kumar

Thanks for the suggestions.

**Martijn (admin)** Sat Mar 28, 2015 11:08 pm

Martijn (admin) wrote:
anu_d wrote:
==>Dear Martijn,
If one predicts using "his" model......and he gets the right answers that are validted.....then I have no worry.
Right answer means he is able to validate the past events in the +/-1 year window

Proof is in the pudding....isn't it

Dear Anu_d,

From my point of view, my perception on this 'pudding' is... I have seen no proof at all! - All I see are conflicting models and unsubstantiated claims/observations.

In this perspective, using a different method... should simply lead to a different result!
I hope we can agree on that!?

And basically, if everybody is using a different method... and finds EXACTLY the same result: 'my method is right'... I think that should raise a very serious question:

What is really going on here in this matter???
(I think there is at least a lot of psychology and subjective observation involved)

But I noticed in your answer that you do not share my worries. So, I guess you provide no space at all for a thorough discussion - since you assume that your model works just fine.

Sorry, I think that these 'time'-models merely create illusions - simply because people want to attribute meaning to any characteristic of the hand. All 'time'-models factually violate Holtzman's fundamental no.1 rule of modern hand reading! (I hope you are aware of that rule)

Anyway, thanks for sharing your thought.

5 Years later I can add: all timing models not only violate Holtzman's no.1 rule... they also violate the basic principle of Multi-Perspective Hand Reading, which suggest that at least 3 dimensions of the hand are required to get involved in order to establish a reliable assessment.

More details: http://www.multiperspectivepalmreading.com/

(So, whatever system you choose for timing the fate line... the fundamental issue is that users of time models for the hand always felt satisfied with 'anecdotal evidence', because nobody ever presented any credible attempt that could represent a first step towards objective proof for any of such models - by the way, the high amount of different models can be recognized to represent a clue that nearly all of these models - if not all - are very likely not reliable at all... which concerns basically a matter simple logics!)

which time scale of fate line fits in your practice? - Page 2 Multi-perspective-hand-reading-banner-2014

**nishaghai** Mon Mar 30, 2015 9:23 am

pravin kumar wrote:Dear Hok,

Benham has different chart, Cheiro has different chart and Narayan Dutt Shrimali has a different chart. Benham takes the maximum age a person lives to be 70. I am quoting from memory, Cheiro takes it as 91 or 98 (Systems of seven) and Narayan Dutt Shrimali takes it as 100 years. Now neither is right or all are right. Which method you want to follow and get results is the best method for you. If you have some other chart in your mind or way of calculation and it brings you success well and good. I am inspired by W.G. Benham but for age I follow Cheiro's method in which I get good success. In the case of Heart Line though I follow the starting point to be below the Jupitor Finger, centre of the mount and from there I calculate the age. I take that to be the starting point and the ending below the mercury finger.

Once I had a discussion with Ed Campbell and he said he follows it the other way round. Actually we were discussing about a palm print in that forum. It so happened that both ways the age was correct as the point was in the centre of the heart line. Still I told him that whatever method is followed should give us the correct result.

Secondly if you read palms regularly and your desire is to solve other persons problems genuinely you will find your intuition going stronger and you will be surprised at yourself when you start giving the age predictions.

Pravin Kumar

I agree with Praveen I Follow Chiro Method and its correct . As If the palm is long or square then the calculation change . what i have seen that if we mark the junction point of Heart or head Line with Saturn it change as per shape of hand .
Nisha Ghai

Sponsored content

which time scale of fate line fits in your practice?